Exiled primordial hydra returning

Started by Iamjohnnybutt, June 13, 2013, 03:38:27 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Iamjohnnybutt

If my opponent plays {fiend hunter} and exiles my {primordial hydra}, then fiend hunter dies an brings my primordial hydra back, if in that instant he comes back, could I cast {hunger of the howlpack}, or {bioshift}, being as they are both instants, and they have priority, to either add or move counters onto primordial hydra and result in it not dying?

Keyeto

Those cards require a creature to be on the battlefield (obviously, but there is a point to this). As soon as the Hydra hits the battlefield, it dies because of a state based action. State based actions do not use the stack, and cannot be responded to. I'm afraid the Hydra won't make it.

Gorzo

The only way to save the hydra is if you have a static effect on the board before the hydra returns that would improve it's toughness as it enters the battlefield.  {Veteran Armorer}, for example.

Crisys

Or  {Master Biomancer} if I'm
Not mistaken since creatures enter with a minimum or 2 +1/+1 counters on them

Destore117

I always thought when cards exiled and returned they returned to play in the same condition as when they left unless the card states otherwise :/

Paraluke

Exiled creatures "return" as new creatures unless stated otherwise.

Destore117

Quote from: Paraluke on June 13, 2013, 08:24:04 PM
Exiled creatures "return" as new creatures unless stated otherwise.
Alrighty