Un-genius card ideas

[MisterJH]

Post some ideas that you thought were revolutionary.. Before realizing how absolutely awful they were. For example: my eyes lit up as i began to design... A sorcery speed counter spell!

[Apathy Reactor]

a card that costs 10 colorless energy that ends the game as a tie for all players, as an instant XD

[MisterJH]

Likeminded genius!

[Apathy Reactor]

like you are in a four person multiplayer game and everyone else has 10+ hp and you only have like 2 but you have a ton of mana... BOOM 4-way tie! call it involuntary peace treaty or something XD

[MisterJH]

Haha itd be the most popular deck ever

0% losses
0% wins
100% ties

Its a {door to nothingness} deck but 10x easier to pull of lol. I can just imagine modern 'Urzatron Tie-machine' dominating everything

[Dudecore]

Someone asked Mark Rosewater about a sorcery speed counterspell, to which he appropriately replied "you could never cast it." It's pretty funny when you think about it.

I once had an idea for a faux Ramp deck that didn't ramp into anything - just made the opponent conserve resources waiting to answer what would never come. It tested it out, turns out things don't work like that.

[MisterJH]

Haha like tron affinity? Its revolutionary

[Crapshooter]

You know, they could make a sorcery speed counter spell meant for modern, make it 1-2 CMC and give it some outrageous upside and then see how many people connect it with  {Alchemist's Refuge}.

[Dudecore]

You know, they could make a sorcery speed counter spell meant for modern, make it 1-2 CMC and give it some outrageous upside and then see how many people connect it with  {Alchemist's Refuge}.

Wouldn't it just be a 4 mana counterspell then? {G}{U} to activate it, {T} on the Refuge and {1} for the spell? If it had a {Rewind} effect, that could work.

[Crapshooter]

Or even make it cost 0 and say "counter target spell, draw cards equal to its converted mana cost"

[Apathy Reactor]

I still like my idea of a card that just ends the game XD

[Crapshooter]

 {Karn Liberated} closest thing yet

[Apathy Reactor]

I'll admit, {Karn} looks alot cooler when he is liberated

[Apathy Reactor]

lol I guess normal Karn isn't a card, but in the digital magic world, he is a planeswalker

[Crapshooter]

I think if your card was made it would have to be Karn's picnic, I just want to see a happy karn