Gisela and inquisitors flail

[5/9 Turtle]

If I have  {Gisela, Blade of Goldnight} and equip  {Inquisitor's Flail} to it does it deal 4x the damage or just 2x

[Birdbrain]

4X. Both say double damage don't they?

[Birdbrain]

And you can't damage enchantments and lands??!!? Her text says "permanent"

I guess they didn't want to say creatures and planes walkers to save space. That must be it

[Coffee Vampire]

She would deal four times her damage (two, multiplied by two), because she has two effects that double damage.

The damage abilities are replacement effects, which stack. It's similar to {Rhox Faithmender}. Also, you can find in the rulings of {Inquisitor's Flail} that equipping two of them will multiply damage by four.

RESOLVED

[5/9 Turtle]

Awesome thanks, I'm thinking that to keep a creature from dying to make it indestructible

[Birdbrain]

But she decreases damage taken by half, so she would cancel out the negative effect of the flail

[5/9 Turtle]

Well if something is still big enought to kill her

[Birdbrain]

Well if something is still big enought to kill her

true

[5/9 Turtle]

Or even putting it on  {Fencing Ace} with both out and the flail on him

[Birdbrain]

Or even putting it on  {Fencing Ace} with both out and the flail on him

and boost his power to 5. 20 damage on a single turn

[5/9 Turtle]

But if someone blocks it its pretty much dead, and with both out and power of 5 that would be 40 in one turn, he has double strike

Yeah I already made that deck it's paired with a crap ton of enchantments and  {Sphere of Safety}

[Birdbrain]

No. I was already factoring double strike plus the flail

5X4=20

[5/9 Turtle]

Oh I was saying with gisela out, looks like one of us has a great mind

[Birdbrain]

Oh I was saying with gisela out, looks like one of us has a great mind

you right?

[5/9 Turtle]

They say great minds think alike, I know both of us have great minds to be able play magic, my great mind must have failed for a couple of minute