Reckless Brute & Blood Reckoning

[Sovenrim]

When player target attack me with  {Reckless Brute} he loose 1 life when I have  {Blood Reckoning}?

[Iandtormentor]

Yup 👍 as  {Blood Reckoning} says when ever a creature atks you the take damage even if they have no choice

RESOLVED

[Sovenrim]

Is that any creature that will not trigger abilities of  {Blood Reckoning}?

[Iandtormentor]

Not any i can think of now

[MisterJH]

Creatures that do not attack, otherwise i doubt it.

[Kaleo42]

 {Geist of Saint Traft}
The angel will not trigger the reckoning since it wasnt declared an attacker, it is made already attacking

[Sovenrim]

{Geist of Saint Traft}
The angel will not trigger the reckoning since it wasnt declared an attacker, it is made already attacking

But Geist is attacking...

[MementoMori]

Right. Geist will trigger it, but the angel won't. So your opponent will lose one life even though two creatures are coming at you.

{Hero of Bladehold} works the same way.

[Sovenrim]

Yeap, so there is no creature that will not trigger  {Blood Reckoning} in attack phase.

[Keyeto]

Yeap, so there is no creature that will not trigger  {Blood Reckoning} in attack phase.

It only triggers when a creature is declared as an attacker. The angel token {Geist of St Traft} creates was a good example. Another one is {Kaalia of the Vast}; whatever creature she puts into play with her effect won't trigger it.

[Sovenrim]

Yeap, so there is no creature that will not trigger  {Blood Reckoning} in attack phase.

It only triggers when a creature is declared as an attacker. The angel token {Geist of St Traft} creates was a good example. Another one is {Kaalia of the Vast}; whatever creature she puts into play with her effect won't trigger it.

Yes but before Kaalia put creature she must attack (if I'm not wrong) and after this controler loose one life. I was asking about creature on battlefield with effect like Kaalia but without put this creature to attack.

[Keyeto]

Yes but before Kaalia put creature she must attack (if I'm not wrong) and after this controler loose one life. I was asking about creature on battlefield with effect like Kaalia but without put this creature to attack.

This is true, I was just giving another example of something that would work. She does have to attack, but you can still get an extra attack with her (well, the creature she puts into play) without taking the damage.

[Sovenrim]

Returning to {Blood Reckoning} there is not written that controller of attacking creatures get -1 life for each attacking creature but only -1 for this action and doesn't matter if he or she attack with 5 or 1 creature, right?

[Keyeto]

Returning to {Blood Reckoning} there is not written that controller of attacking creatures get -1 life for each attacking creature but only -1 for this action and doesn't matter if he or she attack with 5 or 1 creature, right?

If they attack with 5 creatures, they'll lose 5 life. The keyword is "Whenever". This means that every time a creature attacks, it sets off a trigger and life will be lost.

[Sovenrim]

Damn, that's why I lost because we didn't know that.
Thanks for explain.