You make the card 4

[loop-s-pool]

For the red card to complete the 2 drop cycle what effect would it need? I was thinking something like at the beginning of your upkeep ? deals 2 damage to target creature or player. 2/1 of course.

[Gorzo]

For the red card to complete the 2 drop cycle what effect would it need? I was thinking something like at the beginning of your upkeep ? deals 2 damage to target creature or player. 2/1 of course.

It would have to at least be as good as {Hellspark Elemental}.

[Bozo_Law]

Would a  {Hellspark Elemental} that didn't get exiled after being unearthed be too good?

Most definitely.

[Birdbrain]

Would a  {Hellspark Elemental} that didn't get exiled after being unearthed be too good?

thats a good strategy. Unearth the elemental, then vanish it so it stays in play

[Trunksthemighty]

Where is {vanish in to memory} useful? I think it can be used for getting a few extra cards, but you also have to throw them away when it comes back.

Could also be good for something like  {Primordial Hydra}

[Darius]

Well, it seems that the card is either going to be an enchantment or a land.

http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Article.aspx?x=mtg/daily/feature/239

[Baneslayer]

Well, it seems that the card is either going to be an enchantment or a land.

http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Article.aspx?x=mtg/daily/feature/239

Yes Enchantment

[Wackaman9001]

I voted enchantment, you know we need another goodie

[Hays413]

Also enchantment.
Twice now lol

[Silent1236]

Land!

[Hays413]

Land!

BOOO!!!
HISSS!!!

[Gorzo]

Gotta go with enchantment. There are so many possibilities there to be creative with wild, new things. With land, it feels a bit more restricted - what can a land potentially do that an enchantment couldn't potentially do and then some? Not have a mana cost, I guess, sure, but that's being greedy! And that greed comes with a price of what the card's power level comes to.

[Birdbrain]

Gotta go with enchantment. There are so many possibilities there to be creative with wild, new things. With land, it feels a bit more restricted - what can a land potentially do that an enchantment couldn't potentially do and then some? Not have a mana cost, I guess, sure, but that's being greedy! And that greed comes with a price of what the card's power level comes to.

I want to take this challenge and make up something creative, and balanced with the land thing. Though I agree there is more design space with enchantment, and that will probably be what gets choosen. I'm sure whatever gets made will be cool

[Raven316]

When is the next voting?

[Hays413]

When is the next voting?

The current vote (Echantment vs. Land) ends Friday I believe. Then I assume the next vote (color?) starts Monday.