Planeswalker show down

[Bman0121]

Who do you think would win in a fist fight,  {Sorin Markov} or  {Jace Beleren}? No magic just a sraight up fist fight

[Mikefrompluto]

Sorin. Based off his abilities in his various card forms, he's more aggressive.

[Bman0121]

Sorin. Based off his abilities in his various card forms, he's more aggressive.

Im just saying like no abilities like if they boxed eachother who would win

[Fenster]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon >  Elpeth > koth > Sarkhan > domri > tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraskai > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Domri upped in rank due to feedback! Koth added ^^

[Vyse]

Alright a demigod level planeswalker, surviving for just as long as bolas, vs some pre-teen brat that is dependent on his magic for everything. I'm going to go with sorin, especially with no magic involved 

[Birdbrain]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Hello? Karn is made of freaking metal! I'd put him above Sorin

And technically isn't Urza a planeswalker?

[Fenster]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Hello? Karn is made of freaking metal! I'd put him above Sorin

And technically isn't Urza a planeswalker?

Well karn is purely magical so i took him out. I also only used printed pw's for convenience

[Birdbrain]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Hello? Karn is made of freaking metal! I'd put him above Sorin

And technically isn't Urza a planeswalker?

Well karn is purely magical so i took him out. I also only used printed pw's for convenience

Technicaly, if you take magic out of the equations, there are no planeswalkers. Because they became so through magic. So, that's why I included Karn. But let's just agree to disagree

Oh and {Karn, liberated}

[Fenster]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Hello? Karn is made of freaking metal! I'd put him above Sorin

And technically isn't Urza a planeswalker?

Well karn is purely magical so i took him out. I also only used printed pw's for convenience

Technicaly, if you take magic out of the equations, there are no planeswalkers. Because they became so through magic. So, that's why I included Karn. But let's just agree to disagree

Oh and {Karn, liberated}

They're all enteties that gained "a spark"
Karn without his spark is a hunk of metal whilst sorin is still a vampire and jace is just human.

And i know that karn is printed i was talking about urza.

[Birdbrain]

Karn was a living robot before he got his spark. So technically he could still count

[Mikefrompluto]

Sorin. Based off his abilities in his various card forms, he's more aggressive.

Im just saying like no abilities like if they boxed eachother who would win

I know exactly what you're saying. Im basing my judgment off of their abilities. Sorin's is more aggressive, so he's probably in better physical shape than Jace. Jace is obviously in better intellectual shape than Sorin, but probably hasn't flexed his muscles much as Sorin has.

Tl;dr Sorin's abilities suggests he's more combat-minded than Jace.

[Mikefrompluto]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Hello? Karn is made of freaking metal! I'd put him above Sorin

And technically isn't Urza a planeswalker?

Well karn is purely magical so i took him out. I also only used printed pw's for convenience

Technicaly, if you take magic out of the equations, there are no planeswalkers. Because they became so through magic. So, that's why I included Karn. But let's just agree to disagree

Oh and {Karn, liberated}

Dude, enough with the technicalities already. You know what the OP meant by "no magic."

[Missingkirby34]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Dissagree, why is domri so low? You'd thnk living with the gruul clans and being around so many violent people and animals he would have experience, especially in a fight.

And on another note I would love to see the movie based of this thread, maybe entitled "Planeswalker Games" a spoof of "Hunger games"? It just seems right

[MarduArrow]

In pure physical combat id say:

Nicol bolas > Ajani > Garruk > Sorin > Gideon > Elpeth > Sarkhan >  tibalt > chandra > jace > liliana > vraska > domri > nissa > Tezzeret.

(Tezzerets arms are magical so he'd badically be a magicarp.)

Tibalt would eledgedly have some kind of demon infused strength in this scenario.

Karn is also pretty much living magic so he's a noshow.

Dissagree, why is domri so low? You'd thnk living with the gruul clans and being around so many violent people and animals he would have experience, especially in a fight.

And on another note I would love to see the movie based of this thread, maybe entitled "Planeswalker Games" a spoof of "Hunger games"? It just seems right

Domri isn't very big tho and on another note, seeing as Sorin is a vampire he would technically be stronger than Garruk who is (unless I'm mistaken) a human

[Missingkirby34]

Domri isn't big, but I'd be willing to bet he is agile and evasive, one of those monkey like pro fighters who just dodge everything and get enough small hits in