Plasm capture, savageborn hydra

Started by 5/9 Turtle, May 25, 2013, 10:38:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

5/9 Turtle

If I were to counter the hydra with  {Plasm Capture} would I also get the x value or just two mana

{Savageborn Hydra}

Keyeto

You would only get the two. X counts as 0 when determining converted mana cost.

Giggle the Draco Genius

Actually while a card is on the stack X is equal to how much is paid. Anywhere but the stack X is equal to 0

202.3b

Kagain123

You are correct giggle. It states on  {Plasm Capture} rulings that you gain the value of X. If someone casts  {Fireball} to deal 5 damage, you would gain 6 mana (5+ R)

RESOLVED

Paraluke


Double-O-Scotch


Gorzo

From Gatherer:

Rulings
4/15/2013   If the countered spell had {X} in its mana cost, include the value chosen for that X when determining how much mana to add to your pool. For example, if you counter a spell that costs {X}{R} with X equal to 5, you'll add six mana to your mana pool.

Giggle is correct.

5/9 Turtle

Quote from: Giggleflat on May 25, 2013, 12:15:03 PM
Actually while a card is on the stack X is equal to how much is paid. Anywhere but the stack X is equal to 0

202.3b

This works with any x valued card right

Keyeto

Sleep deprivation = bad answers.

Sorry about that, guys. Not sure what I was thinking there! Thanks for cleaning up after my poor answer :P

Keyeto

Quote from: Mozilla butcher on May 25, 2013, 03:11:36 PM
Quote from: Giggleflat on May 25, 2013, 12:15:03 PM
Actually while a card is on the stack X is equal to how much is paid. Anywhere but the stack X is equal to 0

202.3b

This works with any x valued card right
Correct. Unless otherwise stated, no card is an exception to the rules!

prayos

 {Plasm Capture}ing a  {Sphinx's Revelation} is into my own is so much fun.