Ethics of Planesmanders

[DimirOverlord1300]

I don't like them... Wizards keeps making commander products that print some fun stuff but also screw up a lot... Looking at you kaalia/derevi/oloro/Edric.

Not sure I can agree with the comment that Kaalia's broken. Derevi definitely is. Oloro's just stupid. Not sure about Edric though.

Kaalia can be degenerate, it depends. And yes I have played against the Edric player the intelligentlemen is talking about. Screw {Triumph of the Hordes}.

[Silent1236]

I don't like them... Wizards keeps making commander products that print some fun stuff but also screw up a lot... Looking at you kaalia/derevi/oloro/Edric.

Not sure I can agree with the comment that Kaalia's broken. Derevi definitely is. Oloro's just stupid. Not sure about Edric though.

Kaalia can be degenerate, it depends. And yes I have played against the Edric player the intelligentlemen is talking about. Screw {Triumph of the Hordes}.

Haha I played a much more degenerate Edric and skipped {Triumph of the Hordes}.  Play lots of little dudes, take lots of turns, use lots of recursion, ping to death with little dudes. Stupid good and cheap, too

I like the idea of planeswalkers as commanders. They may be a bigger threat, but they're easier to answer. You can't just attack {Iona, Shield of Emeria} like you can a PW. A Planeswalker is always a huge target. I think these guys are no different. None of them seem broken. Nahiri is good, but not broken. I'd love to be able to use any PW as a commander. {Tamiyo, the Moon Sage} mono {U} control 😍

[MuggyWuggy]

Time to buy all dem foil kill PW spells

[xStrayKnightx]

I don't like them... Wizards keeps making commander products that print some fun stuff but also screw up a lot... Looking at you kaalia/derevi/oloro/Edric.

Not sure I can agree with the comment that Kaalia's broken. Derevi definitely is. Oloro's just stupid. Not sure about Edric though.

Kaalia can be degenerate, it depends.

I have people try and take me out first just cause I play Kaalia. Then they discover that my bond with Kaalia isn't a competitive one, and they relax. Very rarely will my Kaalia deck be ridiculously fast-paced and aggressive.