Horde of boggarts

Started by ibtrickey, March 02, 2014, 11:50:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ibtrickey

 {Horde of Boggarts}
Do basic mountains count? And red goblin tokens?

Rass

#1
If the card that generates the tokens says red then they will count. (Can link card for better answer)

As far as the land I would say no but I'm just guessing. (I would wait until someone with more knowledge answers)

And don't forget to count the card as one

Quisequise

#2
Lands are colorless check out  {Ancient Stirrings}

202.2b: Objects with no colored mana symbols in their mana costs are colorless.


ibtrickey

But a red goblin token has no mana..

particle

Quote from: Ibtrickey on March 03, 2014, 12:15:50 AM
But a red goblin token has no mana..

but a red permanent doesn't need mana symbols to be red. {goblin rally} puts in red goblins. as long as they have a color identity defined, they have color, mana cost not required.

Destore117

105.3.: Effects may change an object's color or give a color to a colorless object. If an effect gives an object a new color, the new color replaces all previous colors the object had (unless the effect said the object became that color "in addition" to its other colors). Effects may also make a colored object become colorless.

Won't the effect of the card stating to put "colored" tokens replace their "colorless" status and make them the specified color?

particle

yes if it tells you the token is a specific color, it has that color identity. its not colorless.

ibtrickey

So then how is a mountain colorless when it produces red?

Destore117

Because thems the rules
"Lands are colorless"

ibtrickey


Destore117

Ok. Well I believe this is resolved. Right?

ibtrickey


ibtrickey

I always forget that originally they stated they tap to produce the color