Curse of deaths hold vs undying

Started by Ghstify, March 15, 2012, 07:34:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ghstify

I had a curse of deaths hold on my brother which had a strangleroot geist, we Played it as it coming back numerous times until I players massacre wurm. Is that a instant death for him?

Spikepit

Quote from: Ghstify on March 15, 2012, 07:34:14 AM
I had a {curse of deaths hold} on my brother which had a {strangleroot geist}, we Played it as it coming back numerous times until I players {massacre wurm}. Is that a instant death for him?
I don't think it would bring him back numerous times. Undying says it can't come back it has a counter on it, where as Deaths Hold doesn't put counters on creatures, it just changes the P/T.

However, the Wurm would insta kill the root with the effects of the curse in play.

ryannorris16

Right the +1/+1 counter is still on the creature after it came back. It's just the original p/t is reduced be the curse.