Messages

Funny and interesting question... The "only" basic land im seeing for commander is snow-covered... Wonder why that is............. (to check this i filtered the type and format...) wierd

At the place where i go its called "snipe" you are allowed to "watch" games but you cannot biuld decks to counter another players deck...

With all do respect i am a dick... But that also doesnt mean "should a player look at a card s/he is not legally able to" (also to teach, like should a person have a lure effect on a creature with deathtouch and designate all damage to one creature and not several, only that one creature dies) should be either forced to concede or have the game end in draw... I perfer to have the game end in draw rather than force a ff... Sheesh (although i understand your point) lets not get into a fight online about it? Because then we both look like techno-geek body-builder wannabies!

They have access to the information on the other side of the card. Personally I would find grabbing other players materials without asking to be poor sportsmanship. Like grabbing their library and counting the card remaining or grabbing their graveyard. It's rude, but not flat out illegal. You could ask them to ask first and if they refuse, a judge might intervene in those terms.

Ty ill have to get more clarification on this...  Perhaps from mtg itself...

Okay, lets look at this from another angle... Yes the card is placed on the battlefield faced up, transform however causes the card to be flipped, also causing a new object to appear on the field, what im asking is can privilaged information cause a player to force a concede for looking at a privilaged side of a transform card?

In laymens terms answer simple "yes" or "no" otherwise i can carry this argument on all day... Lol

The flip side is an object however, and it IS face down...

Rule 707.5 does that mean they are forced to concede?

Well i brought this issue up to a judge in a league, there was no rule he could think of that states "you must ask to look another players card" therefore i stated "so you may as well play the game hands viewable?" he came back with "well thats the way the games played" so i stated "well [privilaged information] means that i know my deck better than someone elses, therefore if there is NO privilaged information you may as well play the game placing the cards openly viewable on the table "unless" there is a card in league play that allows you to look at one anothers cards" he replyed "leagues already started so... Cant change the rules now" and i stated "then we all play cards viewable" everybody got angry and i havent been back in to see if theyre still playing that way... (its been 2 weeks and its a weekly league) so... Just wondering... Is it possible to force a concede for an instance as such stated above... (because there is a card in legendary that if you ask to look at it you lose... Thats why i brought up this issue)

Can looking at a card (persay a double faced card) in play, without asking to look at the card, (to see both sides) force a concede in standard league play? (looking for tournament/league rules unless stated otherwise)

Okay lets give a example in-game senario... I have in play the double faced garruk (both sides have pictures, both sides do something different) is it legal for my opponent to pick up and look at that card (both sides) without prior permission to do so?

Correct, infect is delt as damage is delt, it is a state based action because the damage MUST resolve, unless you can permenetly make a creature bigger, when your using infect, the creAture dies (kimda like putting an instant on a creature, the instant resolves at end of turn and the creature dies cuz its in a negative format -1/-4 ect) the damage does not resolve (i believe) until end of combat... Please correct me if im wrong

As per this question... Declare attack... Declare blocks... After the declaration of blocking instants/abilities can be activated... Then the battle occures... Should an instant OR an ability remove counters PRIOR to the battle going on, a creature with undying comes back... Period... (-1/-1 counters arent placed as per SBA's untill AFTER the battle and after creatures die, therefor normal damage is delt untill AFTER death...)
As per does anti-matter destroy matter... Yes... Yes it does... More "matter" that an atomic bomb would destroy... Per say...

( thank you mtg online and mtg for ps3 for answerig this question)

Okay thx that helps a bunch when it comes to my next infect deck...

A side question: say my oppenent has 1 life and i have 2 1/1 creatures and he has 57 creatures. I use Lure on one of my creatures and swing with both i win correct?

That would be hularious.

That poor jerk who invested in all those {Relentless Rats} would be so sad.

I know someone with a deck like this and has invested quite a bit in trample cards, as well as a few planeswalkers... (he left angry) but what he failed to realize is i had lifes finally and a creature that dealt damage to target opponent when it and every other creature dies... Ida won anyway...

Should an undying creature die, the ability resolve, and hex parasite is on the playing field, can hex parasites ability be used to remove the counter to keep the creature alive over and over until he (hex parasite) is killed?