Messages

Hello everyone,

I want to get a huge playmat for my playgroup.
I checked online And i found that some xwing play mats pretty cheap and fit the dimension i need.
The thing is the playmat is in vinyl instead of our classic rubbish mousepad material. Does anyone know if if this is a big deal or it would work great anyway ?

Still trying to get last post...

No, you only get one untapped trigger from golem, as it is a "beginning of upkeep" trigger
The Oracle text (updated text) has taken away the activated ability, and has instead given it a triggered ability.

In fact, the Ooze doesn't even get the ability, since it is triggered and not activated.
Similarly, if you have a {goblin sharpshooter}, for example, Ooze will not untap if a creature dies.
Try {pili-pala} with {training grounds}. It is pretty much a free untap that way.

Oh... I didnt noticed the oracle text. Yeah well i guess this kind of wording doesnt exist anymore for a reason. Thanks for the pilipala tips. And thanks for your answer both of you :)

Hello,

I'm trying to figure a {necrotic ooze} deck.
I've come accros {soldevi golem}. Les say i have {gelectrode} and golem in graveyard and the ooze on the battlefield. At my upkeep can i make a loop and go infinite damage?

Does Progenitus have to resolve in the graveyard for scions effect if so it doesn't work

Scion doesn't care what happens to the creature, it just attempts to throw it away.

Not sur about this one. can someone enlighten me with more explanation?

Yeah, interaction of replacement effects is pretty complex, as it works quite different from triggered effects on the stack.

Can't reproduce an example for a controller-less object in this instance. In the case of damage, the source pretty much always has one.

Plenty of times. An object only has a controller when it is on the stack or in play. In any other zone, an object has no controller, only an owner.

So if, for example, two replacement effects were trying to get you to discard a card for different reasons, then the owner of that card (i.e. you) makes the decision. The card in your hand has no controller.


^^ from a mtg salvation ruling discussing 419.9a

Thanks :) learned again today. Working my way to the 100post to give karma to everyone !

The affected object's controller (or its owner if it has no controller)

Can you give me an example of this? An object can be controlled by noone ??

Took me 4 reading but got it thanks. So theres no way for me to kill my opponent in this setup.
unless he makes an error.

Hi, sorry I'm late ;)

In this case, we have two prevention effects trying to modify damage dealt.
Rule 616 handles with replacement/prevention effects:

616.1.: If two or more replacement and/or prevention effects are attempting to modify the way an event affects an object or player, the affected object's controller (or its owner if it has no controller) or the affected player chooses one to apply, following the steps listed below. If two or more players have to make these choices at the same time, choices are made in APNAP order (see rule 101.4).
So, the controller of the source (your opponent) chooses which effect applies first. If he chooses to apply palm last, there will be no damage to prevent for Palm, as all has been prevented. Thus, your opponent will not receive damage. If, on the other hand, he applies Palm first, he will not gain life.

The battlefield is only one zone that exists for both player. Unlike a graveyard, there's two graveyard and one battlefield. So it doesn't leave/enter the battlefield again

It will also count shocklands duallands and battle land if they are plains-xxxxx

Evolving wild read :
Tap, sacrifice : do something.
Everything before the ":" is the cost of the ability and is paid before anything else happens.
Such as the trigger of {mine layer}.
As mickeven stated, the trigger will still go on the stack but will fizzle.

Hmmm
I could be wrong, I may have misread a strike, that is a delayed prevention effect.


SUMMON KAYLESH!!

Yeah we definitively need some of the top end rulers! The amount of posts also helps me understand why my friend and i argued for about 30 minutes about this.

Is there a way for me to make 7dmg to my opponent. Maybe by stacking/casting in correct order ?

My opponnent attacks with a 7/7 creature . I cast a {deflecting palm} on the attacking creature. Before it resolve opponent cast {awe strike} on his own creature
What is going to happens ? Will my opponent take 7 dmg or will he heals 7 life?

I think both spell create a delayed ability. In apnap order, i put my deflecting palm delayed ability on the stack then my opponent put his awe strike delayed on the stack. But it feels weird anyway. Anyone can enlight me ?

Really?

Exactly this.
I learned alot today thanks to everyone who posted there

I dont see why not. Theres no time where they will be 2 legendary cards with the same name on the field.