Rolled a 20
I'd like to play one but it would have to wait for tomorrow if you're down to play then.
I'm down
You don't have cockatrice do you?
Only Magic Workstation
Ready when you are.
I'm ready
I rolled a 14 so go ahead.
Play an island
Pass
20/6
Play {elhame palace}
Pass
40/6
(playing EDH right?)
Oh, sorrry
Untap draw
Play island
Pass
40/6
Untap, draw
Play mountain
Tap elhame and the mountain for {cream of the crop}
Pass
40/6
Untap draw
Play an island
Pass
40/6
Untap, draw
Tap mountain for { Wildfield borderpost} bringing back the mountain to my hand.
Play mountain
Pass
40/5
What's border post do? Cloudpost comes up
Untap draw
Play an island
Play {Renegade Doppelgänger}
Pass
40/5
That's my bad. I fixed it.
Untap, draw
Play forest
Tap forest, mountain, and elfhame for
{obelisk of naya}
Pass
40/4
Untap draw
Play {Wee Dragonauts}
Pass
40/4
Untap, draw
Tap mountain, forest, and elfhame for my commander {mayael, the anima}
Pass
40/5
Mana leak that elf
Untap draw
Play {Steam Vents}
Pay 2 life
Play {Niv Mizzet} my commander
Use my doppelgänger and tap to draw
You lose 2
Pass
38/4
Untap, draw
Play forest
Remove {razia's purification} and {meglonoth} from the game to play {sunscour}.
Tap all my lands and the two artifacts for mayael
Pass
38/2
Untap draw
Play an island
Play Niv Mizzet
Pass
38/4
Untap, draw
Tap my lands and the two artifacts for {mayael, the anima}'s ability.
Play {platinum emperion}
Pass
37/3
Untap draw
1 to you
Play an island
Play {Blue Sun's Zenith} for 5
5 to you
Swing with Niv Mizzet
Pass
38/8
Take 4 general damage. My life total can't change because of emperion
Untap,draw
Play plains
Tap all lands and my artifacts for {angelic arbiter}
Pass
37/7
Have to concede. No removal
That emperion is nasty!!
What's general damage?
The emperion was lucky too. You would have tore me up with niv.
If I'm not mistaken, if you take 21 damage from someones commander you lose the game.
Quote from: Jenningst on July 18, 2012, 04:31:55 PM
If I'm not mistaken, if you take 21 damage from someones commander you lose the game.
:D
Just 20.
And with one swing.
Not added up.
Quote from: Kuberr on July 18, 2012, 04:40:11 PM
Just 20.
And with one swing.
Not added up.
Don't listen to Kubs, he lies. It's a sum total of 21 over the whole game. You need to track that as well. (One thing I don't like about commander, but I heard it's to speed up stale-mates.)
Resolved! *gavel*
Quote from: BlackJester on July 18, 2012, 04:44:41 PM
Quote from: Kuberr on July 18, 2012, 04:40:11 PM
Just 20.
And with one swing.
Not added up.
Don't listen to Kubs, he lies. It's a sum total of 21 over the whole game. You need to track that as well. (One thing I don't like about commander, but I heard it's to speed up stale-mates.)
Resolved! 🔨
I sometimes wonder if you just make stuff up to sound like you know what youre talking about.
I may be wrong sometimes, but when I watch sanctioned tourneys. And this is what the judges tell me. I don't like to think they're wrong.
Quote from: Kuberr on July 18, 2012, 04:46:58 PM
I sometimes wonder if you just make stuff up to sound like you know what youre talking about.
I may be wrong sometimes, but when I watch sanctioned tourneys. And this is what the judges tell me. I don't like to think they're wrong.
I can be wrong from time to time, but not this time. CR903.14a.
Edit: Also, FWIW, I usually double check the ruling before I post here.
Yeah, BJ's got it (surprise ;) ). All the rules I've ever read say 21 damage or more, total. Which is also why, I believe, there's a commander damage option on the life counter on this very app.