My friend had a {Strangleroot Geist} out, and I killed it and the Undying activated. Then, next turn, he attacks with it again. I block with my 2/2 infect, does the -1/-1 counter remove the +1/+1 or does it make it so the Geist has 1 +1/+1 and 2 -1/-1's? Would the undying trigger again or would the Geist die?
Undying triggers again
geist dies for good.
I call for jester
Which is it???? lol
I agree with scars. It would kill it.
rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.
Quote from: Rokitchikin on June 17, 2012, 02:41:08 PM
It would remove the +1/+1 then add a -1/-1. Which would reduce the toughness to 0 and destroy it. Then undying would trigger again.
It would come back because of undying. It just says "When this creature dies." So putting a -1/-1 on it would still "kill" it, would it not?
Quote from: scarsabrex on June 17, 2012, 02:42:19 PM
rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.
Awesome! Thanks! :D
Quote from: scarsabrex on June 17, 2012, 02:42:19 PM
rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.
and for those who fail to read
I win
Retract all previous statements thanks scars.
Quote from: Millionlittlee on June 17, 2012, 02:46:01 PM
I win
you called jester... I answered. you most certainly did not win.
I said it first and I called jester because I didn't know the rule number
Quote from: scarsabrex on June 17, 2012, 02:47:57 PM
Quote from: Millionlittlee on June 17, 2012, 02:46:01 PM
I win
you called jester... I answered. you most certainly did not win.
Ya the rule is saying that you are wrong. So I don't see that as a win
Lol this guy.
....unless I missed the memo about opposite day!!!! Damn you google calendars!!!!
it's ok guys this is the same person who said sorin markov and sorin's vengeance planeswalker ruled themselves.
Quote from: scarsabrex on June 17, 2012, 02:56:14 PM
it's ok guys this is the same person who said sorin markov and sorin's vengeance planeswalker ruled themselves.
He did what????
It's over, I am pretty sure the question of this thread has been answered. Not to be damper on the fun you guys seem to be having but it seems we are just making fun of people now. Time to move on maybe?
go into combo corner and find the combo sorin's puzzle. it's on the first page i think. read the discussion.
Quote from: Coffee Vampire on June 17, 2012, 03:02:08 PM
It's over, I am pretty sure the question of this thread has been answered. Not to be damper on the fun you guys seem to be having but it seems we are just making fun of people now. Time to move on maybe?
This^ -_- I got my answer a while ago
I thought positive and negative counters couldn't co exist on a creature. So there would be no +1/+1 and then undying should trigger again.
... the rule# has already been posted
You don't need to evoke the Jester. There are many capable rules people lurking aroun here. Scarsabrex, for one, is solid.