Creature (24)
4x {Birds of Paradise}
1x {Courser of Kruphix}
4x {Eternal Witness}
1x {Gaddock Teeg}
4x {Knight of the Reliquary}
1x {Qasali Pridemage}
2x {Scavenging Ooze}
1x {Sigarda, Host of Herons}
4x {Stoneforge Mystic}
1x {Thragtusk}
1x {Thrun, the Last Troll}
Land (23)
1x {Dryad Arbor}
9x {Forest}
9x {Plains}
4x {Windswept Heath}
Artifact (3)
1x {Batterskull}
1x {Sword of Fire and Ice}
1x {Umezawa's Jitte}
Instant (4)
4x {Swords to Plowshares}
Sorcery (4)
4x {Green Sun's Zenith}
Enchantment (2)
2x {Sylvan Library}
Sideboard (15)
1x {Choke}
1x {Containment Priest}
2x {Eidolon of Rhetoric}
1x {Krosan Grip}
1x {Nevermore}
1x {Peacekeeper}
2x {Pithing Needle}
1x {Qasali Pridemage}
2x {Selesnya Charm}
1x {Sword of Light and Shadow}
2x {Thalia, Guardian of Thraben}
How do yall like it?
This is basically nic fit without the nic fit parts. So basically bad nic fit. Like this deck is unplayable.
Btw to your mana confluences were not near mint and you cannot say your opinion is different because there is an actual scale to determine this.
Ya seriously dude. You can't do stuff like this regularly.
Well I've play tested this deck, and it works very well so idk
Quote from: Rothsteine on June 18, 2015, 08:51:31 PM
Well I've play tested this deck, and it works very well so idk
We're talking about you sending me ridiculously HP confluences calling them nm
Quote from: Kaalia with haste on June 18, 2015, 10:04:06 PM
Quote from: Rothsteine on June 18, 2015, 08:51:31 PM
Well I've play tested this deck, and it works very well so idk
We're talking about you sending me ridiculously HP confluences calling them nm
Yeah... I could tell
Quote from: Taysby on June 18, 2015, 08:58:19 PM
Have you played it vs ant, show and tell, delver, etc instead of other casual legacy brews? This deck is not that good. It's running courser... Knight of the reliquary is way too slow. Gaddock stops 1 card. Force of will. So they'd just force it instead. (Yes, I know other things do exist, but rarely will he stop them). And it also stops your own green sun. Sigarda does... Nothing? Thragtusk does not give you the value you need from 5 mana. No {savvanah}/{temple garden}. Id play {sensei's diving top} over library. The side is just as lackluster.
{tarmogoyf} is needed.
Dude, I don't have 1000$ so I can't go and get a playset of {tarmagoyf}'s
I agree I need the divining top, but what late game 4+ drop would you recommend. To sigarda I personally like her but there may be a better card. And like half of legacy blue decks have a force of will, tho I may sideboard it. What do you have against courser and the knight of the reliquary?
Courser is pretty bad it's too slow in legacy. Knight is perfectly fine BUT only it you have good lands to get {Wasteland} {Rishadan Port} {Karakas} {Etc} since you don't have those cards in the deck knight is also unplayable.
Tbh and not trying to be mean but this deck needs a lot of work lomo at Maverick lists on mtgtop8
Quote from: Taysby on June 19, 2015, 02:05:20 AM
Quote from: Mattao19 on June 19, 2015, 01:40:34 AM
Courser is pretty bad it's too slow in legacy. Knight is perfectly fine BUT only it you have good lands to get {Wasteland} {Rishadan Port} {Karakas} {Etc} since you don't have those cards in the deck knight is also unplayable.
Tbh and not trying to be mean but this deck needs a lot of work lomo at Maverick lists on mtgtop8
Knight is only good in the lands deck with dredge where he hits as a 10/10. :P
He's not played in lands. He really only sees play in maverick
Quote from: Taysby on June 19, 2015, 11:16:14 AM
Sorry, mispoke. Didn't mean lands, just the deck that has wastelands, life from the loams, stuff like that. If you have to actually use his ability, he's too slow.
Sorry to keep disagreeing but he's played bc of that ability. You use it twice lock them out then swing with the knight :D
If I take out all the Knights, and add 1 sword of light and shadow, 1 pithing needle, 1 senses diving top and 1 containment priest would that be better? Thou now I would need to edit my sideboard. Also I would put in 4 temple garden
What's a good card instead of {courser of kruphix}, and {gaddok teeg} For my deck. Gaddok would be side-boarded
Honestly and not trying to be rude but your deck is just too weak this kind of deck needs hate cards like {Thalia Guardian of Theaben} otherwise it's just a worse death and taxes
Your almost there to a maverick deck. Which did rule the roost for a couple months a couple years ago.
I think you should look there for some tips.
Also knight of the reliquary was played in legacy junk. So it's not a bad card
Knight is a great card ... When you run 4 Wasteland heck I'm sure ghost quarter would do for now :P
Quote from: Mattao19 on July 10, 2015, 12:16:12 AM
Knight is a great card ... When you run 4 Wasteland heck I'm sure ghost quarter would do for now :P
To search and use a wasteland was a +2/+2 bump and it could do many tricks like use plains sac to find s fetch for another plains play stoneforge for jitte.
Quote from: Mattao19 on July 10, 2015, 12:16:12 AM
Knight is a great card ... When you run 4 Wasteland heck I'm sure ghost quarter would do for now :P
Ghost quarter really doesn't do it. Wasteland is a denial card. Ghost quarter is good for killing stuff like colonnade/tarpir/lighthouse/cavern/urza's lands/valakut/whatever in modern but it's bad for a denial plan unless you also play Leonin arbiter or the bird that lets you search top 4
I know I'm saying ghost quarter incase of budget restrictions
Quote from: Mattao19 on July 10, 2015, 03:29:34 PM
I know I'm saying ghost quarter incase of budget restrictions
I know. I'm saying it's not even worth inclusion if you don't have wasteland it's not worth it