I am currently involved in a trade with {rothestine}. The trade involved some of my cards for his 3 mana confluences. Today he tells me that my confluences have gone to someone on pucatrade and I will be receiving his cards soon, if I haven't already (which I haven't). Currently I don't see an attempt to remedy this situation. This post isn't to start a witch hunt. It's to warn users that issues like this may arise when trading with Roth. It is also of note that this is our second trade, in our first I received 2 VERY heavily played watery graves that were advertised as lightly played and my compensation was an {Eldrazi temple}. I can post pictures of the graves if needed ( I haven't been able to unload them due to their condition). Also of note, if this was the first time something had gone wrong and his writing was on some level comprehensible, and there was a clear attempt to be remedying this then I wouldn't be mad. But when I mess up a trade with someone I make SURE that it doesn't happen again, and they're given accurate compensation.
TL;DR: Rothestine has proven himself twice to be a poor trader through poor communication, misrepresented card condition, and mixed up traders.
This should be a trial, also, he is on a send first policy. Also middleman trades with him are highly encouraged. Hopefully he fixes the problem with you
I will copy and paste to trial section. My bad.