situation: EDH
I have {ajani steadfast} in play and I use his emblem. Now all damage dealt to me / planes walker I control is reduced to 1.
Ok, so if my opponent had {child of alara} as their commander and had dealt 16 damage to me before I got the emblem out, if they swung with alara for 6, would the total commander damage dealt by alara be raised by 6 or by 1?
If that was confusing, ask and I will further explain myself :D
You would take 1 damage
Yea, but would the amount of commander damage go up by 6 or 1?
By 1. Why would it go up by 6?
I don't know, I thought that since the commander dealt six, but it's reduced to one would mean something,
Well, thanks :D +1
Quote from: Popper23345 on January 03, 2015, 03:00:28 PM
I don't know, I thought that since the commander dealt six, but it's reduced to one would mean something,
Well, thanks :D +1
It only ever deals 1. It swings in for X, and it is reduced to 1 before any damage is dealt.