Why does everyone think {Prognostic Sphinx} is so awesome ?
Because scry 3, it doesn't die by removal or board wipes, and it doesn't die to elspeth
Dat beard that's why
It dies to wipes...
Really?
Its the answer to Elspeth, that's why. It does die to boardwipes, boardwipes don't target so Hexproof does nothing to stop them.
Quote from: Dudecore on August 16, 2014, 10:07:14 PM
Its the answer to Elspeth, that's why. It does die to boardwipes, boardwipes don't target so Hexproof does nothing to stop them.
Wow how didn't I know that
Quote from: RUGmonster on August 16, 2014, 10:55:03 PM
Quote from: Dudecore on August 16, 2014, 10:07:14 PM
Its the answer to Elspeth, that's why. It does die to boardwipes, boardwipes don't target so Hexproof does nothing to stop them.
Wow how didn't I know that
Bc you play RUG lol jk :P
Also it's a solid control finisher (obvi AEtherling is better) but he rotates soon
IMO he is like {Pack Rat}. It's not necessarily good, there is just nothing better to replace it.
Idk I think he's great. One of the best rares to draft and in a control deck that's drawing cards he's almost untouchable. But he does get tapped down a lot which is a huge downside :(
Quote from: Mattao19 on August 18, 2014, 11:09:15 AM
Idk I think he's great. One of the best rares to draft and in a control deck that's drawing cards he's almost untouchable. But he does get tapped down a lot which is a huge downside :(
This about it this way: Pretty much every time you tap him down to give him hexproof, you're trading cards 1-for-1 with Removal spells, but you still have your fatty. Sphinx is solid. Unless Khans says otherwise, he might be the finisher of choice for control decks. Not as easy to protect as AEtherling, sure, but you get to blank spot removal by trading a card.
Quote from: Remillo on August 18, 2014, 11:51:52 AM
Quote from: Mattao19 on August 18, 2014, 11:09:15 AM
Idk I think he's great. One of the best rares to draft and in a control deck that's drawing cards he's almost untouchable. But he does get tapped down a lot which is a huge downside :(
This about it this way: Pretty much every time you tap him down to give him hexproof, you're trading cards 1-for-1 with Removal spells, but you still have your fatty. Sphinx is solid. Unless Khans says otherwise, he might be the finisher of choice for control decks. Not as easy to protect as AEtherling, sure, but you get to blank spot removal by trading a card.
Exactly!
Except (sadly) he dies to wipes unlike AEtherling :(
Quote from: Remillo on August 18, 2014, 11:51:52 AM
Quote from: Mattao19 on August 18, 2014, 11:09:15 AM
Idk I think he's great. One of the best rares to draft and in a control deck that's drawing cards he's almost untouchable. But he does get tapped down a lot which is a huge downside :(
This about it this way: Pretty much every time you tap him down to give him hexproof, you're trading cards 1-for-1 with Removal spells, but you still have your fatty. Sphinx is solid. Unless Khans says otherwise, he might be the finisher of choice for control decks.
This. The only other resililiant threat we have is {Reaper of the Wilds}, but that is a ground creature, requires a commitment to GB, requires mana to activate the ability, and is god awful against Elspeth were as Dumbledore Sphinx is amazing against her.