{Karn Liberated}
{AWOL}
Would the creature come back in the new game karn creates, if so I guess it's not "absolutely-removed-from-the-freaking-game-forever zone"
You'd have to ask MaRo (the one and only un-rules judge) if you want a real ruling. Otherwise, whatever you and your friends decide is what goes. Gotta love un-cards :P
RESOLVED
Quote from: abstractApathist on February 10, 2014, 11:30:18 PM
You'd have to ask MaRo (the one and only un-rules judge) if you want a real ruling. Otherwise, whatever you and your friends decide is what goes. Gotta love un-cards :P
More than life itself, where is un3 when you need it.
Well... Looking at this as logically as possibly (considering an Un-card is involved), I don't see any way for Karn and AWOL to interact. If it was exiled by Karn, there's no way it could be targeted and absolutely-removed-from-the-freaking-game-forever by AWOL, and visa versa, right?
Sorry didn't make a situation where this would happen, john attacks jane with {Avacyn, Angel of Hope}. Jane casts {AWOL} in response, avacyn is now in the "absolutely-removed-from-the-freaking-game-forever" zone. John casts {Karn Liberated} and 2 turns later ultimates. Does avacyn get shuffled back or stay in the "absolutely-removed-from-the-freaking-game-forever" zone?
Gah...un rules! I miss this stupidity :P I want un3 dammit!
I would think she'd get get shuffled back because it's starting a new game and clearing all zones, but honestly I could see just as valid of a logical argument for leaving her in AWOL. Someone get the MaRo signal! We have a crisis!
I believe both awol and angel of hope would be left out since they werent exiled by karn
I say that it is removed forever, and the card exiled by AWOL is marked and never used in another game of magic again...
It's removed from the game "forever" zone.
So perhaps after your set of 3
It's up to you, I just thought of it when I saw it posted on another thread and it hit me. Figured it would be a good question for the t1s and t2s we have out there.