What happens when you put gift of immortality on something like kitchen finks or young wolf? Do they come back with counters?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but you could choose either. It could either get the Persist and not have Gift, or not get Persist and get Gift (I think we all know what to choose)
{Gift of Immortality}
{Kitchen Finks}
{Young Wolf}
Just being helpful.
I would thing they would come in with no counters as undying states "when this creatures dies.........", and does not state "when this creature moves from the graveyard to the battlefield....."
You have to choose. You could make the stack:
Top
Immortal
Undying/Persist
Bottom
And the card would come back with no counters. If you made it:
Top
U/P
Immortal
Bottom
The card would come back with a counter. And the Gift would still come back and attach at the end step.
Quote from: Wingnut on September 24, 2013, 09:04:04 PM
I would thing they would come in with no counters as undying states "when this creatures dies.........", and does not state "when this creature moves from the graveyard to the battlefield....."
Dies literally means moves from field to graveyard. It it an M12 revision they made to save space.