{Rancor}
{Black Cat}
Here's the scenario. My opponent has a Cat on the field. I have a creature with two Rancors. My hand is empty. On his turn, my opponent casts {Mutilate}. Here's how we played this out:
1.) Mutilate cast. All creatures entered the graveyard.
2.) Cat's trigger is put on the stack since he's active player.
3.) Both Rancor's trigger is put on the stack.
4.) Both Rancor's go to my hand.
5.) Cat's trigger resolves, forcing me to discard one of the Rancor's.
I agree with this, but I want to make certain we did it right. Thoughts?
Seems fine to me. Triggers go on the stack in APNAP order, so your rancors would resolve first.
Awesome. That's what I thought. :D I'm glad I came up with that. :D
Rancor goes to the hand after the enchanted creature dies, and black cat and the enchanted creature died at the same time. Basically, you didn't have any cards to discard, so black cat doesn't work, then your rancors go to your hand.But you don't have believe me, because I'm no expert.
Quote from: dexis on July 25, 2013, 11:20:43 AM
Rancor goes to the hand after the enchanted creature dies, and black cat and the enchanted creature died at the same time. Basically, you didn't have any cards to discard, so black cat doesn't work, then your rancors go to your hand.But you don't have believe me, because I'm no expert.
Your answer is unnecessary and misleading.
The correct answer has already been given and explained why it is so.