I know this is going to open a huge can of worms, but I have never seen Star Wars or Star Trek. My mother thought they were both stupid; so I never watched either. Now that I'm married to a Star Wars fan and best friends with a Trekkie, I need to know what are the pros and cons of both. Right now I'm leaning towards Star Trek thanks to Chris Pine. (I loved him in This Means War and Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement.) However, Star Wars is now owned by Disney giving it a huge plus.
Depends on if you want quality or quantity. Star Trek has three different series set in the universe and countless movies, whereas Star Wars has three amazing movies and three not-so-amazing movies. Really you could get into both. You can easily watch all of Star Wars in two days and then start on the Star Trek legacy.
Personally I think Star Wars is better. I grew up on it, but I have only just recently gotten into Star Trek, so my opinion is biased.
STAR WARS. It will teach you betrayal, responsibility, the difference between good and evil, action and consequence, not to mention the wisdom in retaining international marketing rights.
Star Trek is a soap opera. A space opera, if you will. It will teach you everything that isn't possible, or almost possible, scientifically. Now that said, "wrath of khan" kicked ass as did the lady's man of a captain who always managed to get his shirt off.
But STAR WARS is a legendary epic. One that I find as rewarding as homer's "the Iliad" and "the odyssey".
Star Trek is basically a space-based sitcom.
Star Wars Pros
-Action Packed
-Great Story
-Memorable Characters
-Immersive universe
-Epic Lightsaber Battles
Star Wars Cons
•no one in the movie can aim a gun worth poo
•you may not know what anyone is talking about
Star Trek Pros
-Lots of Material
-Immersive Universe
-Many Settings
Star Trek Cons
-Characters aren't extremely unique from one another
-Much more Drama
-You may not know what anyone is talking about.
Quote from: Mikefrompluto on May 12, 2013, 05:53:31 PM
Star Trek has three different series set in the universe and countless movies,
Star Trek has 5 sets Mike...;)
ST: Original series
ST: Next Generation
ST: Deep Space Nine
ST: Voyager
ST: Enterprise
And 11 movies.... 12th is coming soon...;)
This is a toughie for me as I grew up with both. Probably Star Wars is the better choice.
Oh I think there is no way how to pick only one of them...
Both are incredible stuff.. I am quite sure that you will end up by watching both if you are interested in Sci-Fi...;)
My suggestion is watch both of them and see which one you like. There is no law saying you must like only one of them.
Quote from: Juggernuat9060 on May 13, 2013, 09:42:04 AM
My suggestion is watch both of them and see which one you like. There is no law saying you must like only one of them.
True. I was blind for 37 years, Star Wars only. I've seen my first two Star Trek movies last week, and while Force will always be with me, I'm a Trekkie now ;)
Quote from: whitedrake on May 13, 2013, 02:14:50 AM
Quote from: Mikefrompluto on May 12, 2013, 05:53:31 PM
Star Trek has three different series set in the universe and countless movies,
Star Trek has 5 sets Mike...;)
ST: Original series
ST: Next Generation
ST: Deep Space Nine
ST: Voyager
ST: Enterprise
And 11 movies.... 12th is coming soon...;)
Ah I forgot about Deep Space Nine and Voyager! Im still on TNG right now.
Starwars is pretty cool. Except the prequel garbage and other expanded universe things.
The barrier of entry for Star Trek is too great. Hundreds of episodes and things. The JJ Abrams movies are the "New World Order" of Star Trek. It makes the series approachable for a new audience. With that being said, they're really just action movies with explosions and people shooting each other. The "science fiction" element has been removed, making it more "science fantasy" like Starwars. Meant to appeal to the lowest common denominator - popcorn eating audiences who wouldn't stand for an honest treatment of the source material.
I do like JJ Abrams for his use of real sets and actors. Instead of jamming cartoon monsters onto a screen and CGI everything (like Lucas).
Quote from: Mikefrompluto on May 13, 2013, 09:47:22 AM
Quote from: whitedrake on May 13, 2013, 02:14:50 AM
Quote from: Mikefrompluto on May 12, 2013, 05:53:31 PM
Star Trek has three different series set in the universe and countless movies,
Star Trek has 5 sets Mike...;)
ST: Original series
ST: Next Generation
ST: Deep Space Nine
ST: Voyager
ST: Enterprise
And 11 movies.... 12th is coming soon...;)
Ah I forgot about Deep Space Nine and Voyager! Im still on TNG right now.
I love all sets...;) And honestly one of my favourites is Deep Space Nine... It shows the universe from a little different point of view... ;)
Quote from: Dudecore on May 13, 2013, 09:57:44 AMThe JJ Abrams movies are the "New World Order" of Star Trek. It makes the series approachable for a new audience. With that being said, they're really just action movies with explosions and people shooting each other.
Respectfully, I disagree. What makes Star Trek interesting and head and shoulders above an average action movie is Spock and his interactions with normal people, especially with Kirk's ethics. Granted, I'm weird :P
I personally like Star Trek better, I've seen all of them over a period of a year and they were fun to watch
Star Wars is really close to as good but I liked Star Trek better
I like the more fantasy ish stuff lol. Star wars since im just lukes father. Am i right? Or AM I RIGHT?!?!
How about Star Ward meets Star Trek?
well just call it... STAR... or Trek Wars.
I go 'I'm your father' on my daughters sometimes ;)
I love star wars it is awesome it has amazing games the movies are really good and easy to follow but there is always a dark side to thing( see what i did there?) and the dark side is named jar jar......
I just saw the new Star Trek film. I change my vote to Star Trek! 👍👍👍👍👍
Lol...traitor...jks
We're comparing apples and... maybe pineapples. Both have sort of similar names and both have fruity goodness but they are really fundamentally different. Star Trek has great social commentary with a very optimistic view of our future. Star Wars has all the best elements of storytelling with a grittier (when it's at its best) view of "people". I say both win the contest.
Although if I had to pick, dogfights and swords that are lasers probably tip the scales in Star Wars' favor.
+1 sir. I am sooo biased lol
Anyone listen to Rod Roddenberry's Mission Log podcast? Its basically MST3K-style but more serious. He talks about the theme behind the chosen Star Trek episode. Pretty cool.
Old Star Wars > Old Star Trek, Newer Star Wars < Newer Star Trek. I know this is an old thread, but after seeing the newest Star Trek I felt inclined to comment.