iMtG Server: Gathering

Cull The Meek 90 cards, 0 sideboard 2 {Orzhov Guildgate} 12 {Swamp} 12 {Plains} 26 lands 1 {Yotian Soldier} 1 {Abattoir Ghoul} 1 {Wight of Precinct Six} 1 {Skyhunter Patrol} 1 {Smog Elemental} 2 {Basilica Guards} 3 {Basilica Screecher} 1 {Daring Skyjek} 1 {Myr Enforcer} 1 {High Priest of Penance} 1 {Niblis of the Mist} 1 {Vizkopa Guildmage} 2 {Kingpin's Pet} 1 {Nim Lasher} 1 {Angelic Page} 2 {Titanium Golem} 1 {Guardian Lions} 2 {Tundra Wolves} 1 {Shadow Alley Denizen} 4 {Omega Myr} 1 {Zarichi Tiger} 1 {Tormented Soul} 1 {Balustrade Spy} 1 {Master Decoy} 1 {Treasury Thrull} 1 {Cathodion} 1 {Knight of Obligation} 36 creatures 1 {Infiltration Lens} 1 {One Thousand Lashes} 2 {Dying Wish} 1 {Righteous Charge} 1 {Gift of Orzhova} 1 {Chromatic Sphere} 1 {Tanglebloom} 2 {Leonin Scimitar} 1 {Sunbeam Spellbomb} 1 {Crippling Blight} 2 {Angelic Edict} 1 {Loss (Profit/Loss)} 1 {Executioner's Swing} 1 {Break of Day} 1 {Purge the Profane} 1 {Gather the Townsfolk} 1 {Mask of Memory} 1 {Blinkmoth Urn} 1 {Tooth of Chiss-Goria} 1 {Blood Reckoning} 1 {Second Thoughts} 1 {Necrogen Spellbomb} 1 {Curse of Oblivion} 1 {Midnight Recovery} 1 {Murder} 28 other spells Sideboard Notes: Trade Godless Shrine for Sorin Markov, need to get Riot Control, Sinister Possesion

Simply looking for Critique

The first piece of advice would be to trim your deck down to 60 cards. After doing that, you will want a playset of your staple cards that make the deck run. Before I can help you any further, I need to know what you want this deck to do. Right now it is all over the place and needs to be more focused on one game plan with a potential back up plan B.

Quote from: Death Gaara on May 12, 2013, 04:10:11 AM
The first piece of advice would be to trim your deck down to 60 cards. After doing that, you will want a playset of your staple cards that make the deck run. Before I can help you any further, I need to know what you want this deck to do. Right now it is all over the place and needs to be more focused on one game plan with a potential back up plan B.

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:12:29 AM

Quote from: Death Gaara on May 12, 2013, 04:10:11 AM
The first piece of advice would be to trim your deck down to 60 cards. After doing that, you will want a playset of your staple cards that make the deck run. Before I can help you any further, I need to know what you want this deck to do. Right now it is all over the place and needs to be more focused on one game plan with a potential back up plan B.

Lol woops quoteception there.
Anyways I like being able to keep my life flow steady not dropping while being able to stop monsters and well just kinda poke at them until their decks fall.this is what I want to be able to do.
And the myr are there for extortion and also just kinda an unexpected twist to confuse my opponents. (mainly i need aid cuz I play against Rakdos and Mill decks that crush me every time :'( )

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:15:33 AM

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:12:29 AM

Quote from: Death Gaara on May 12, 2013, 04:10:11 AM
The first piece of advice would be to trim your deck down to 60 cards. After doing that, you will want a playset of your staple cards that make the deck run. Before I can help you any further, I need to know what you want this deck to do. Right now it is all over the place and needs to be more focused on one game plan with a potential back up plan B.

Lol woops quoteception there.
Anyways I like being able to keep my life flow steady not dropping while being able to stop monsters and well just kinda poke at them until their decks fall.this is what I want to be able to do.
And the myr are there for extortion and also just kinda an unexpected twist to confuse my opponents. (mainly i need aid cuz I play against Rakdos and Mill decks that crush me every time :'( )

I see, so might I comprise a list for you then? I can build one that stops creatures, Mill, and maintains a flow of life rather easily.

That would be most helpful.
As long as it stays black white.
Because I truly don't have the funds to deviate from that path.

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:20:41 AM
That would be most helpful.
As long as it stays black white.
Because I truly don't have the funds to deviate from that path.

Here is a list based on what we talked about. This is more of a streamlined aggressive control list designed to deal with what problems you have been facing with other decks.


Creatures- 16
4 {Vampire Nighthawk}
4 {Basilica Guards}
4 {King Pin's Pet}
2 {High Priest of Penance}
2 {Treasury Thrull}

Enchantments- 6
4 {One Thousand Lashes}
2 {Pacifism}

Spells- 8
4 {Tribute to Hunger}
2 {Consuming Vapors}
2 {Merciless Eviction}

Artifacts- 4
2 {Mindslaver}
2 {Elixir of Immortality}

Planeswalkers- 1
1 {Sorin Markov}

Lands- 25
13 {Swamp}
9 {Plains}
3 {Orhzov Guildgate}

The premise is simple. Against aggro decks you keep removing threats and gaining life. You should be able to win a war of attrition and blow them out with a Mindslaver or Sorin. Against control you keep laying the threats down (do not overextend). Against mill you have elixir and a way faster clock then them. This list is pretty budget friendly and should be doable to build. I have every card listed if you need any of them. Keep in mind that this is not a standard deck and is just a casual deck that I tailored to answer the problems you have been facing up to this point.

Quote from: Death Gaara on May 12, 2013, 04:43:49 AM

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:20:41 AM
That would be most helpful.
As long as it stays black white.
Because I truly don't have the funds to deviate from that path.

Here is a list based on what we talked about. This is more of a streamlined aggressive control list designed to deal with what problems you have been facing with other decks.


Creatures- 16
4 {Vampire Nighthawk}
4 {Basilica Guards}
4 {King Pin's Pet}
2 {High Priest of Penance}
2 {Treasury Thrull}

Enchantments- 6
4 {One Thousand Lashes}
2 {Pacifism}

Spells- 8
4 {Tribute to Hunger}
2 {Consuming Vapors}
2 {Merciless Eviction}

Artifacts- 4
2 {Mindslaver}
2 {Elixir of Immortality}

Planeswalkers- 1
1 {Sorin Markov}

Lands- 25
13 {Swamp}
9 {Plains}
3 {Orhzov Guildgate}

The premise is simple. Against aggro decks you keep removing threats and gaining life. You should be able to win a war of attrition and blow them out with a Mindslaver or Sorin. Against control you keep laying the threats down (do not overextend). Against mill you have elixir and a way faster clock then them. This list is pretty budget friendly and should be doable to build. I have every card listed if you need any of them. Keep in mind that this is not a standard deck and is just a casual deck that I tailored to answer the problems you have been facing up to this point.

My dear friend Death.
This. Is exactly what I want.
If only there was some way to just have this deck.... >.<
I have like 8 cards from it (excluding land of course lol)

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:48:41 AM

Quote from: Death Gaara on May 12, 2013, 04:43:49 AM

Quote from: Destore117 on May 12, 2013, 04:20:41 AM
That would be most helpful.
As long as it stays black white.
Because I truly don't have the funds to deviate from that path.

Here is a list based on what we talked about. This is more of a streamlined aggressive control list designed to deal with what problems you have been facing with other decks.


Creatures- 16
4 {Vampire Nighthawk}
4 {Basilica Guards}
4 {King Pin's Pet}
2 {High Priest of Penance}
2 {Treasury Thrull}

Enchantments- 6
4 {One Thousand Lashes}
2 {Pacifism}

Spells- 8
4 {Tribute to Hunger}
2 {Consuming Vapors}
2 {Merciless Eviction}

Artifacts- 4
2 {Mindslaver}
2 {Elixir of Immortality}

Planeswalkers- 1
1 {Sorin Markov}

Lands- 25
13 {Swamp}
9 {Plains}
3 {Orhzov Guildgate}

The premise is simple. Against aggro decks you keep removing threats and gaining life. You should be able to win a war of attrition and blow them out with a Mindslaver or Sorin. Against control you keep laying the threats down (do not overextend). Against mill you have elixir and a way faster clock then them. This list is pretty budget friendly and should be doable to build. I have every card listed if you need any of them. Keep in mind that this is not a standard deck and is just a casual deck that I tailored to answer the problems you have been facing up to this point.

My dear friend Death.
This. Is exactly what I want.
If only there was some way to just have this deck.... >.<
I have like 8 cards from it (excluding land of course lol)

I do believe I said I have every card listed if you need them (it may have slipped my mind as I am really tired at the moment). I sent you a PM regarding all of the cards you are missing.