Ok
I summon vorinclex. My opponent act of treasons it. I cancel, but he uses fiery fall, sacs it, and gets three mana. Can he do that?
If he legally takes control of your creature, he can sac it. I use {act of treason} and {fling} in a deck I have. I then say thank you for your creature, he attacks you, then I fling him in yo face, and I sum it all up with a closing argument of BOOYA!!!
Ok
Quote from: Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker on February 20, 2012, 12:00:43 PM
Ok
I summon vorinclex. My opponent act of treasons it. I cancel, but he uses fiery fall, sacs it, and gets three mana. Can he do that?
Let's get some links here:
{Vorinclex, Voice of Hunger}
{Act of Treason}
{Cancel}
{Fiery Fall}
If you Cancel his Act of Treason, he won't have control of Vorinclex to sac it for anything. The Act is still waiting to resolve.
Also, I think you meant {Infernal Plunge} instead of {Fiery Fall} (Infernal=Fiery, Fall=Plunge ðŸ˜,), and since the plunge is a Sorcery, your friend couldn't have cast it in response to anything. He needs a slap in the face with the Rule Book. 😱
Ok cool! I have a rule book I can spare......
But if he {cancel}ed {act of treason} his opponent never gained control of his creature to sac it. Or did I read the scenerio wrong?
Right...he never gained control to sac. That is why I said "if he legally gained" control then he could sac. I thought the question pertained to sacing someone's creature if you gained control temporarily.