Hey guys I'm back I wanted to explain my situation because my parents think i'm stealing and im not. I recently took apart my legacy deck (which i traded out) to make a standard deck. Its been a month since our trades and I know thats a long time and im sorry for that I honestly didnt realize how long it had been. anyways Im still skeptical of trades so i always wait for them to come in to me first before i send out. and since i made quite a few when i walk into my room i always stop stare at the pile of stuff to sort through and walk away. so i want to clarify that our trades are in fact still valid i am just lazy. please pm me again and remind me of what our trade is its getting hard to switch between sent and inbox to figure things out. Idk why this didn't post ??
Pertinent information highlighted in red --DC
I am waiting on a {Verdant Catacombs}, a Sorin Markov, commander {sol ring}, {Sword of Feast and Famine}, {Life's Finale}, and a {Fact or Fiction} from you.
My shipping info:
Justin Benner
1825 S Medina Line Rd
Copley, OH 44321
I sent to you on 1/23/2013...please PM if you have further questions.
I PM'd you but I never got a response, so im posting here. I sent you one {dragonskull summit} for two {tree of redemption}. I'd like my {dragonskull summit} back, please and thank you. Here's where you can send it
Mike Harris
215 Sand Beach Blvd
Apt 2008
Shreveport, LA 71105
Be advised that this is a public forum. You're making your personal information available to everyone.
Quote from: Dudecore on February 27, 2013, 09:45:37 AM
Be advised that this is a public forum. You're making your personal information available to everyone.
That is correct.
Another Louisiana guy cool.
As a victim of this whole situation and owner of this forum, taking into consideration the damage caused to the reputation of this forum, I punish Ericlay95 and Ericlay94 with 100 negative karma.
By iMtG law and logic, this does not in any way affect punishment rights to which other victims are entitled to.
I would appreciate if people inform us when they have received their end of the deal with Ericlay95/Ericlay94, please. Everyone is strongly advised not to send anything to Ericlay9x unless their end of the deal was received from Ericlay9x ok, until further notice.
Quote from: Piotr on February 27, 2013, 02:25:10 PM
As a victim of this whole situation and owner of this forum, taking into consideration the damage caused to the reputation of this forum, I punish Ericlay95 and Ericlay94 with 100 negative karma.
By iMtG law and logic, this does not in any way affect punishment rights to which other victims are entitled to.
That's alittle harsh Piotr. He realized his mistake and is now fixing it. Let him fix it, but if he is too slow then you could do this.
Quote from: Piotr on February 27, 2013, 02:25:10 PM
As a victim of this whole situation and owner of this forum, taking into consideration the damage caused to the reputation of this forum, I punish Ericlay95 and Ericlay94 with 100 negative karma.
By iMtG law and logic, this does not in any way affect punishment rights to which other victims are entitled to.
100 seems a little harsh to me for laziness, from what I can tell he always intended to send the cards, he just procrastinated, and you can't tell me that no one else has ever procrastinated at one point or another, I'm not saying there shouldn't be a punishment just that the one that has been meted out is a little more harsh than necessary
Quote from: S717 on February 27, 2013, 04:40:19 PM
Quote from: Piotr on February 27, 2013, 02:25:10 PM
As a victim of this whole situation and owner of this forum, taking into consideration the damage caused to the reputation of this forum, I punish Ericlay95 and Ericlay94 with 100 negative karma.
By iMtG law and logic, this does not in any way affect punishment rights to which other victims are entitled to.
100 seems a little harsh to me for laziness, from what I can tell he always intended to send the cards, he just procrastinated, and you can't tell me that no one else has ever procrastinated at one point or another, I'm not saying there shouldn't be a punishment just that the one that has been meted out is a little more harsh than necessary
He told several people that he had already sent out. Lies. Isn't "don't lie" one of the rules of the forum? 100 is a lot, but if he makes good on his word, he will be getting some positive karma his way.
Quote from: Moneekahh on February 27, 2013, 04:43:57 PM
He told several people that he had already sent out. Lies. Isn't "don't lie" one of the rules of the forum? 100 is a lot, but if he makes good on his word, he will be getting some positive karma his way.
Exactly. If there's no punishment for breaking the law, then what good is it to have the law? He told users he had sent out when he hasn't, and in some cases it simply irritated them, in others it screwed them over. In addition, we can't keep having this kind of thing happen. I'd love to see people able to trade on here without worrying about if they're going to get their cards or not. Events like this make it very difficult to keep a positive trading environment, and cannot continue to be ignored. He broke the law, and was subject to punishment. Simple as that.
Quote from: Moneekahh on February 27, 2013, 04:43:57 PM
He told several people that he had already sent out. Lies. Isn't "don't lie" one of the rules of the forum? 100 is a lot, but if he makes good on his word, he will be getting some positive karma his way.
I was going to agree with you Greg and S717, but I'm definitely going to have to agree with Moneekah and Keyeto now. So, this ^^
Quote from: Silent1236 on February 27, 2013, 04:53:02 PM
Quote from: Moneekahh on February 27, 2013, 04:43:57 PM
He told several people that he had already sent out. Lies. Isn't "don't lie" one of the rules of the forum? 100 is a lot, but if he makes good on his word, he will be getting some positive karma his way.
I was going to agree with you Greg and S717, but I'm definitely going to have to agree with Moneekah and Keyeto now. So, this ^^
Now i don't disagree considering he did lie (apparently). however 100 is still alot. 50 would have been good
100 is perfect to me. It was high time for an example to be made, as this has happened multiple times. And being the programmer and owner of the forum, I assume Piotr can reverse the notion when ericlay makes good on his trades.
Quote from: Mikefrompluto on February 27, 2013, 05:09:16 PM
100 is perfect to me. It was high time for an example to be made, as this has happened multiple times. And being the programmer and owner of the forum, I assume Piotr can reverse the notion when ericlay makes good on his trades.
Not only did he lie, but he continued to pursue trades full well knowing he wasn't sending trades out. This isn't one or two people. This is 10 plus. He continued to trade, accepting cards in the mail, and not sending anything in return.
I do hope he makes good but until he does I support this line of action.
Members should not have to track down other members for cards.
Quote from: Greg54js on February 27, 2013, 04:55:41 PM
Quote from: Silent1236 on February 27, 2013, 04:53:02 PM
Quote from: Moneekahh on February 27, 2013, 04:43:57 PM
He told several people that he had already sent out. Lies. Isn't "don't lie" one of the rules of the forum? 100 is a lot, but if he makes good on his word, he will be getting some positive karma his way.
I was going to agree with you Greg and S717, but I'm definitely going to have to agree with Moneekah and Keyeto now. So, this ^^
Now i don't disagree considering he did lie (apparently). however 100 is still alot. 50 would have been good
This 👆
Yeah, you owe me an elspeth, knight errant for the liliana of the veil I sent you a couple weeks ago. Check your messages for my address
Has he actually messages anyone, he hasn't messages me back yet?
Not i. He used the excuse of PMs not going through when inquired about it a month ago. Which is why I posted my info and such on here, so he couldn't use that as an excuse again.
He PMd me
ours was my 1x {Liliana of the Dark Realms}, which I sent on Feb. 7, for his 3x {Lingering Souls} and 1x {Acidic Slime}.
Return address was on the envelope.
I elsewhere on the open forum have volunteered to be the last one he makes good on, after all the rest of you folks, as the marker for if he finishes.
Question. He has two accounts, each with over 100 posts. Does this make him capable of giving karma to himself?
He has not PMd me
Quote from: AwaySinceMirage on February 27, 2013, 07:38:19 PM
Question. He has two accounts, each with over 100 posts. Does this make him capable of giving karma to himself?
Yes. It would be a form of lying, wouldn't it?
He owes me a {Valakut, the Molten Pinnacle} for my Elesh Norn.
My mailing details are;
Kayle Jones
37 Salamanca Parkway
Port Kennedy, WA 6172
AUSTRALIA
My trade was returned. Kinda sucks since it lost value over the time between. Probably half the reason it was returned and not completed.
Quote from: Johng4490 on March 01, 2013, 06:14:11 PM
My trade was returned. Kinda sucks since it lost value over the time between. Probably half the reason it was returned and not completed.
Same here. What really sucks is I had others ask about the cards I traded before I removed them from my binder.
So my cards were returned, but it doesn't even come close to what I was promised from him. He had promised me extras for the "mess up", but those are still lacking.
I still have received NO feedback whatsoever.. Just saying.
Quote from: MisterJH on March 01, 2013, 08:44:26 PM
I still have received NO feedback whatsoever.. Just saying.
Same here
I just got my {Blood Crypt} back today.
Quote from: MisterJH on March 01, 2013, 08:44:26 PM
I still have received NO feedback whatsoever.. Just saying.
Same here
Im fine receiving my end of the trade back i just want something
I got my card back today too. I guess he didn't have all the cards he claimed to have in my opinion -100 karma is not enough and although I'm grateful my card came back I know have doubts about the whole trading here and I would like for him to be banned because he's been a member for over a year and people will think he is credible
Quote from: Raven316 on March 06, 2013, 09:50:04 AM(...) -100 karma (...) people will think he is credible
If people will think -100 karma makes him credible... well, serves them right :P
Quote from: Piotr on March 06, 2013, 09:53:37 AM
Quote from: Raven316 on March 06, 2013, 09:50:04 AM(...) -100 karma (...) people will think he is credible
If people will think -100 karma makes him credible... well, serves them right :P
Karma is just a number. It be cool if u had lables like cheater/lier/etc. like u have boss/user
Quote from: Empathie on March 06, 2013, 05:14:29 PM
Quote from: Piotr on March 06, 2013, 09:53:37 AM
Quote from: Raven316 on March 06, 2013, 09:50:04 AM(...) -100 karma (...) people will think he is credible
If people will think -100 karma makes him credible... well, serves them right :P
Karma is just a number. It be cool if u had lables like cheater/lier/etc. like u have boss/user
I 100% agree. Even have like troller or something else
Trollin is not stealing
Still nothing in the mail box from him
Quote from: Potticus on March 07, 2013, 04:52:58 PM
Still nothing. 1 more week then we call his mommy again?
Yes
I'm still waiting also, any updates?
Another week of disappointment . Nothing!
An I the only one who has gotten their cards back?
3-4 people have i think, but personally ive given up, and im moving so its hopeless
Quote from: MisterJH on March 11, 2013, 07:53:37 PM
3-4 people have i think, but personally ive given up, and im moving so its hopeless
no it's not. have the mail forwarded and also give him your new address or call his mom and tell her your new address
I wont have a new address until april..
Well I have attempted to contact the household one last time for all the rest of your sakes, but unfortunately I have been blocked from contacting his mother after our last conversation, which was on facebook btw. At least she responded to the initial outreach but looks like she changed her profile so that I can no longer contact her :(
Quote from: NyghtHawk on March 11, 2013, 11:23:43 PM
Well I have attempted to contact the household one last time for all the rest of your sakes, but unfortunately I have been blocked from contacting his mother after our last conversation, which was on facebook btw. At least she responded to the initial outreach but looks like she changed her profile so that I can no longer contact her :(
Her loss, if she wishes her child to grow up a spoiled s**tbag then thats her choice, i just wish it could be made legal so they get their justice
*made a legal matter* just to clarify
Got my cards back from him today.
Thank you to NyghtHawk for making this possible, for the trade was in the $90-$100 range.
On a positive note I now have
2- {Sphinx's Revelation} for trade.
Quote from: Rasser on March 12, 2013, 05:35:02 PM
Got my cards back from him today.
Thank you to Nyghthawk for making this possible, for the trade was in the $90-$100 range.
On a positive note I now have
2- {Sphinx's Revelation} for trade.
I know someone in need of two lol
I'm giving up
Anyone get anything back this week? I haven't nor been communicated with. Just checking.
Quote from: Runningtables on March 20, 2013, 10:08:00 PM
Anyone get anything back this week? I haven't nor been communicated with. Just checking.
Nope!
Nah. I give up.
I'm leaving it. Whatever.