iMtG Server: Gathering

So let's say that I am using an infinite mana deck. (the specific cards do not matter here)
And my opponent is also using an infinite mana combo deck. If I cast {Fireball} (or any other (x) damage dealing spell) and them he counters it with {Syncophate} or {Broken Ambitions} who's spell wins? We both have infinite!

What exactly is infinite mana? Just curious.

To be clear, rules state you must select a number when casting X costs, even with infinite mana. You cannot simply say infinity, you must select a number even if it is a quadrillionmillionbillion time 10. Therefore you cast the spell first, and must select a number, allowing him to select a number higher than yours and counter your spell. The fireball's caster cannot win without an added factor. Infinite v. Infinite the second player must always come out on top according to rules.

RESOLVED

ie. {axebane guardian} + {galvanic alchemist} + whack load of defenders.

Cant actually have infinite. Rules specify you have to designate a finite number.

Well.. 3 defenders in addition to 1 axbane seems to be enough there

Three is a whack load.

So you could {syncopate} his {syncopate} and declare a higher number since your opponent must also specify a finite number.'

Just look up a really big number that practically no one knows exists ending in all 9's and they probably won't be able to tople you. Granted they don't know the number that's bigger

Exactly

I believe they can say, and i would quote, "i have infinite mana so let X equal 1 more mana than you spent on your spell." I would force them to accept that at least.

So what your saying is... Nanana booboo

Hahaha that is precisely what im saying

Holy mother of all things holy,  I despise {U}

Quote from: Double-O-Scotch on February 12, 2013, 10:33:53 PM
Holy mother of all things holy,  I despise {U}

Ditto

It's just so good, I dislike it immensely...

So good... Lol

If you have infinite mana and your opponent has to name a finite number for Syncopate, you would have whatever {X} is and be able to pay it.

You have to name a finite number for fireball first

Lol this is funny ;)

Quote from: MementoMori on February 13, 2013, 12:48:54 AM
If you have infinite mana and your opponent has to name a finite number for Syncopate, you would have whatever {X} is and be able to pay it.

Lol I was about to say the same thing. :)

Quote from: Testset on February 13, 2013, 07:29:48 PM
Assuming, of course, they didn't use ALL their mana and leave their Guardian tapped... 🙈

Oops!

But then you could reapond by adding more mana.