Best Generals in the Format

[Munchlax]

looking to do a poll. I'll start a numbering system. Looking for ideas on what to do next. Big props to {{Mickeven}} for going through the arguments and tallying them for me.

{Narset Enlightened Master} 8

{Zur the Enchanter} 8

{Oloro Ageless Ascetic} 6

{Derevi Empyrial Tactician} 5

{Nekusar the Mindrazer} 4

{Uril the Miststalker} 4

{Arcum Dagsson} 3

{Azami Lady of Scrolls} 3

{Kaalia of the Vast} 2

{Rafiq of the Many} 2

{Prossh Skyraider of Kher} 2

{Maelstrom Wanderer} 2

{Vendilion Clique} 2

{Marath Will of the Wild} 1

{Ruhan of the Fomori}

{Rasputin Dreamweaver} 1

{Jenara Asura of War} 1

{Zedruu the Greathearted} 1

{Sharuum of the Hedgemon} 1

{Edric Spymaster of Trest} 1

{Jhoira of the Ghitu} 1

{Wydwen the Biting Gale} 1

{Geist of St Traft} 1

{Lorthos the Tidemaker} 1

{The Mimeoplasm} 1

{Animar soul of Elements} 1

{Scion of the Ur-Dragon} 1

{Niv Mizzet the Firemind} 1

{Isamaru Hound of Konda} 1

{Sliver Queen} 1

[rarehuntertay]

Nekusar can be badass. But you're usually the number one target

[MuggyWuggy]

Scion for quick finish if needed

[Thetrufflehunter]

Oloro. Stax.

[Ekann1]

Narset hands down.  Zur is a close second.  Both win without allowing anyone else to do anything about it.

This, plus Oloro Stax.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

I'm partial to Arcum. It's my competitive deck. I think it's just straight up stupid.

[JordanCirk]

Oloro stax

[Munchlax]

Updated list

[Spikepit]

If straight winning is your game:
{Zur the Enchanter}
{Sen Triplets}
{Uril, the Miststalker}
{Oloro, Ageless Ascetic}
{Narset, Enlightened Master}
{Athreos, God of Passage}
{Oona, Queen of the Fae}
{Niv-Mizzet, the Firemind}
(Anyone notice a common colour scheme here? Esper for life, baby!)

[Dudecore]

Oloro. Stax.

Narset hands down.  Zur is a close second.  Both win without allowing anyone else to do anything about it.

This, plus Oloro Stax.

Oloro stax

You guys see that many Oloro Stax decks? I'm the only person in my LGS that runs one...
I personally think Arcum is pretty busted. Most Stax decks I've seen run either too many creatures, or they're completely attrition based (like mine). Others run {Ad Nauseam} which has less to do with Oloro and more to running a busted combo in Esper colors.

[DimirOverlord1300]

Derevi, Zur, narset, wanderer, arcum, oloro... There's a lot

[Munchlax]

Derevi, Zur, narset, wanderer, arcum, oloro... There's a lot

Could you like maybe name your top three

[DylanW18]

No one brings up {The Mimeoplasm}? It's pretty degenerate. Copying a {True Name Nemesis} and my commander has protection from you? Or copy {Skitheryx the Blight Dragon} and haste insta win? Or T1 {Entomb} {Jin Gitaxias, Core Augur} into T2 {Exhume}, {Animate Dead}, {Dance of the Dead} etc. gg lol

[Dudecore]

No one brings up {The Mimeoplasm}? It's pretty degenerate. Copying a {True Name Nemesis} and my commander has protection from you? Or copy {Skitheryx the Blight Dragon} and haste insta win? Or T1 {Entomb} {Jin Gitaxias, Core Augur} into T2 {Exhume}, {Animate Dead}, {Dance of the Dead} etc. gg lol

{Sedris, the Traitor King} can do reanimator too. I think the list is looking for broken commanders, not broken colors. Which is why I disagree with Oloro, because {Sen Triplets}, {Dromar the Banisher} and {Sharuum the Hedgemon} every other Esper commander ran Stax before Oloro became the best at it. If he were banned I'd just move my list back to Dromar.

Arcum and Deveri pretty much have decks build around their brokenness.

[Munchlax]

So should Sedris be on the list?